James Van Der Beek
Seeing James Van Der Beek next to Dawson Leery reminds us precisely why we had such a massive crush on him during the 1998 airing of Dawson's Creek when James was just 19.
His irresistible charm still captivates us, evident from that charming smirk! Of course, he continues to pursue his acting career, with recent roles including Matt Bromley in Pose and Grant in the comedy horror film Bad Hair.