Not Telling
Reynolds' plea for answers about Emily in "A Simple Favor" wasn't entirely ignored. Lively was quick to respond with a clever comeback right after Reynolds tweeted his question.
While she didn't directly answer his inquiry, she playfully mentioned that among all the secrets she keeps from him, this one should be the least of his concerns. To add a touch of drama, she even ended her Tweet with an ominous "trust me." But, of course, it was all in good teasing fun, and we know she wasn't truly withholding crucial information from him.
